Plimpton! Starring George Plimpton as Himself is an
affectionate and somewhat superficial portrait of the urban sophisticate who
managed to maintain a persona that was half well-bred man-of-letters and half
common man-of-the-people. Directors Tom Bean and Luke Poling delight in
Plimpton’s self-deprecating humor and the plethora of archival footage he left
behind, but they don’t fully explore the contradictions of the man, nor do we
get much of a sense of his inner life. If you are not already a fan of Plimpton
(as I certainly am) it is hard to see what you would get out of this movie. The
film seems designed to do little more than preserve some specific memories
about what Plimpton did with his life, and give a little insight into why he
was unique; but it doesn’t really make a case for why George Plimpton was
important.