Dirty Wars is a first person documentary about
investigative journalist Jeremy Scahill and his
extensive, boots-on-the-ground research on America’s covert wars and secret
military actions across, what has become, a global battlefield. It is import journalistic
work to be sure; we don’t get many films like this now that George W. Bush is
out of office, despite the fact that the violence and damage done by the US in
the name of the War On Terror has only increased under the Obama
administration. However, like last year’s Chasing Ice, the
film is too focused on the storyteller and not enough on the story. The camera
lingers on close-ups of Scahill as he interviews key figures,
listens to eye-witness accounts, and works at his computer. Coupled with his steely voiceover, this
keeps the viewer at a distance from the facts Scahill is trying to bring to
light, which undercuts the film’s primary goal of bringing the audience closer
to the realities he is reporting on. The approach director
Richard Rowley has taken would work far better as a fictionalized narrative
film about Scahill and the events he is uncovering, rather than an up-close and
personal documentary about him.