Twitter Capsule:
In this adaptation of Garrard Conley’s memoir about a Baptist preacher’s son sent to a gay conversion therapy program, Edgerton and his talented cast underplay all the expected narrative beats. This limited emotional range is both the film's strength - it avoids moral or political posturing in favor of honest human feelings - and its weakness - it fails to fully engage or flesh out character dynamics.
In this adaptation of Garrard Conley’s memoir about a Baptist preacher’s son sent to a gay conversion therapy program, Edgerton and his talented cast underplay all the expected narrative beats. This limited emotional range is both the film's strength - it avoids moral or political posturing in favor of honest human feelings - and its weakness - it fails to fully engage or flesh out character dynamics.