The feature debut of writer, director, and star Jordan Firstman is an engaging but saccharine father-son heartstring-puller about a NYC nightclub and party promoter named Peter whose wild, drug-fueled, sex-filled lifestyle gets derailed when a woman he barely remembers meeting shows up with a 10-year-old kid she claims is his son. This rather by-the-numbers picture received a rapturous response at Cannes, which may help its wide release, but damn it with too high expectations. As someone who enjoys old-fashioned, by-the-numbers narratives with enough of a fresh spin to feel somewhat original, I enjoyed the picture, though I didn't anticipate such a cloying third act. I went in expecting something with a much harder edge, but now that I've seen the trailer, I think most people going in will expect the opposite and may be a little shocked by the first act (though even that feels pretty sanitized for easy consumption by us straights).
We've seen this movie a lot, from The Champ to Big Daddy to C'mon C'mon, so what makes it unique is its contemporary Brooklyn setting and unexpected comedic tone. Firstman lands some strong laughs as both a writer and an actor. The rest of the cast is quite good too, including young Reggie Absolom, also making his feature debut as Peter's son, Arlo. Unfortunately, Absolom isn't really given much of a character to play. Arlo is an idealized, angelic, perfect child that any surprised insta-dad would, of course, fall in love with and want to upend his entire life and lifestyle for. Anyone who grew up in a situation like this, or has known a kid who did, may resent the hell out of how Arlo is depicted in this film, and they'd be right to. It's an incredibly unrealistic and even unfair portrayal, and the movie probably would have been far richer if Firstman had told it from both the father's and son's perspective, and given the son any less-than-lovable attributes. But that's not this picture. This is a maturation plot about a somewhat irresponsible guy living in arrested development who must quickly get his act together and become the responsible father his son needs. On those terms, the movie works pretty well.
Jordan Firstman finds enough fresh angles and earns enough laughs to make his otherwise cloying, overly simplistic maturation picture about an NYC nightclub promoter who suddenly discovers he has a 10-year-old son into a pretty effective heartstring-tugger.

